You know the age of the digital book has come when you get a call from your mother asking for advice on which e-reader she should buy. My mom’s not exactly a luddite, but she is a penny-pinching late-adopter who doesn’t know, or want to know, anything about gadgets.
She knows what she wants from an e-reader–or at least, she thinks she does. She wants a device on which she can read library books. She also wants a device on which she can listen to audio books (preferably those she can obtain from the library). And she doesn’t want a computer to read it to her…she wants the expensively produced audio-books with real actors.
Here’s the (possibly incompetent) advice I wrote up for her:
AUDIO LIBRARY BOOKS
While Kindle will have the computer read a book to you, it will sound like a computer. So, here’s the skinny on audio books that are performed by actors. Almost any of the more modern tablet e-readers will allow you to listen to music or to play audio-books that you buy. However, to get library audio books, your selection is limited. Here’s the site that shows you:
As you can see, renting audio books on most devices are shaded out in gray, except on iPads.
However, if you get a smart-phone in addition to an e-reader, then this shouldn’t be a concern. I listen to audio-books all the time, but not on my e-reader. I use my phone for that. It would be great if I could listen to everything and read everything on one device, but I haven’t been willing to shell out the cash for an iPad. At least not until I’ve sold enough books to pay for my wooden floors
(Apparently you can listen to and manage library audio books on smaller devices like ipod nanos and such–of which I have an extra around here somewhere if mom wants to mess around with that. The difficulty for mom would be the hassle involved in getting the audio books onto the device and I’ve never done it before. I know it can be done, I just don’t know how.)
ANDROID TABLETS
I can’t recommend an Android tablet for you. They are cheaper and they’re nice hardware, but they have a high learning curve. It’s essentially PC vs. Mac on a smaller scale. If you find a PC impossible to navigate, this will probably make you want to throw it out the window when you can’t figure out how to get your library books loaded. It uses the same operating system that my husband has on his phone, and while he is an expert at such things and they work well for him, he advises that you steer clear of any of the google/Android products whether they be tablets, e-readers, or phones.
IPADs
If money isn’t your main concern, iPad may be your best bet as it has no real competition for what it does in the way that it does it.
The old iPads, when last I looked, were $425 but they just put out a new one starting at $499. It’s a lot of money, but if mom doesn’t want to mess around, this is the machine that will do everything for her. It has a camera. It has a keyboard and can be used as a laptop. It will play music for her. She can watch movies on it from anyplace on the internet–not just from the kindle store. I don’t think she can put a DVD into it, but she can stream from Netflix or Amazon or anyplace else. It will do email and everything a computer can do for her. And it’s fully compatible with the library audio books as well as regular books.
More important to mom might be the fact that with an iPad she’s not tied to any one book store. With an iPad, she can buy books on kindle, B&N or really any store that she wants. It will easily handle PDFs and can read ebooks in any format, so she’s not tethered to any store.
It isn’t really an e-reader though. It’s a fully featured machine that can do just about anything. So, I would never pay more than 200 bucks for an e-reader–not when the iPad is within range.
E-INK VS. COLOR DISPLAYS
The only downside to an iPad is that it doesn’t use e-ink. Like all the color devices (including Nook Color and Kindle Fire) it has a backlit screen, which means that if mom is outside and reading on the beach, the sun will glare and it won’t be just like reading on paper.
If that’s a concern to her, she would be better off with an e-ink device like a much cheaper kindle or one of the low-priced Nooks. Ie. Reading in sunlight without glare is going to be a problem for any of the color readers. This is what causes folks to get into flame wars on the internet. Some people refuse to read on backlit screens. Other people want the multifunctions that a backlit color tablet provides.
If mom is going to do most of her reading in audio, however, maybe she doesn’t care about that.
I can share with you my own e-reading experiences. I borrowed the first generation Kindle which was e-ink only, no color backlit screen, and I loved it for what it did. I love e-ink. It’s crisp as paper. However, I was tied to the Amazon store. That was replaced with a Nook first generation with e-ink on the top half and a color screen on the bottom. It has been more than sufficient for my purposes, but I use it only to read.
SMARTPHONES AS READERS
When I want to listen to an audio book, I use my iPhone.
I use my iPhone for quite a lot–including reading books on the fly if I don’t have my e-reader with me. But I can’t recommend it as an e-reader because it’s small and I think it would give you headaches to stare at such a tiny screen for hours at a time. If mom’s going to need a cell phone anyway though, then iPhone is absolutely the way to go, and she can listen to her audio-books on that and have a different much cheaper device for everything else.
(Also, I got an old-model iPhone at the cheapest monthly plan possible, and I’m perfectly happy with it, so there’s no need to go with the newest and most expensive model.)
In summary, if she’s willing to go with more than one device, there’s a potential money-savings there, but not everyone wants to carry around a phone, an e-reader, and a laptop everywhere like I do.
NON-NETWORKED, WIFI, AND/OR 3G
DO NOT buy any e-reader that isn’t equipped with WiFi. You will regret it. You want to be able to walk into your house, have your e-reader connect to your computer network, and access any book store or other internet site. You DO NOT want to rely on your computer to do all your book buying and transfer things over to your e-reader with a plug-in cord. This is a huge huge hassle and it will suck the fun right out of it. Even with my Nook I occasionally have to do computer transfer, but when I do, I want to punch someone, so any e-reader that doesn’t offer you at least WiFi is a huge rip-off.
The question is, do you need 3g in addition to WiFi.
3g basically means that even if you’re out in the woods and there is no internet anywhere around you, you could still connect to the internet if you’re in range of a cell phone tower or satellite or whatever. It’s very handy, and I got it on my Nook without any monthly plan, which is why I love my Nook. Unfortunately, all the device manufacturers caught on to the fact that this was a very expensive service that they were giving away for free…so now you pay a premium for this on any device. (Another reason that I haven’t upgraded to one of the e-readers…b/c right now, I have free internet anywhere.)
If you add a 3g plan onto your iPad it will be costly–and I think it’s a monthly cost of a data plan. Nook doesn’t even offer 3g anymore. Kindle, however, still offers it on two of their e-ink models, and they offer it for life, for free. However, note that they are offering it on those models that are more strictly e-readers, because they know that you’re not going to be watching movies on them.
Now, my thinking is that 3g probably isn’t that important to mom because she’s going to do 99% of her buying and downloading of books in her house. I don’t think she’s going to wait to go out into the woods and suddenly decide she needs to download a movie or check out a library book. In fact, I don’t think she’s even going to go into the woods. The more likely scenario is that she’ll be in the car and want to download something–in which case, all she has to do is pull over into a Starbucks or any other store that offers free WiFi. I’ve done this before. And if it’s really an emergency, I use my phone. (On a cruise, I think 3g is going to be largely irrelevant b/c it’s hard to get any reception at all on the ocean.)
On the other hand, if she’s going to be using the iPad for everything, it could be a good option. I can see her using it in the car to help navigate or look things up on the fly. So that’s a decision to mull over.